Liz and I went to see MAC’s Cham Pale collection the other evening, and I picked up Chilled on Ice and Vintage Selection Paint Pots ($16.50 each). There’s something about a shimmery warm neutral with a strong black liner that sends me over the edge.
I was impressed with the buttery texture of these when applied with a finger, which warms the product up to a nice consistency. Although there are tiny sparkles in these, when applied to the lid I thought that they were pretty and not at all over-the-top, particularly when worn with a matte brow bone color or matte brown in the crease. I would not likely wear Chilled on Ice on the brow bone during the day; I tried it this morning and it was a little glittery for my own taste.
Chilled on Ice applies as a champagne color, essentially a warm cream tone with a touch of gold and silver. Vintage Selection like a rose champagne — a greyed down soft rose with a touch of gold and silver.
Swatch comparisons with other creme eyeshadows in my collection: RMS Beauty’s Living Luminizer, RMS Beauty’s Luna eyshadow, MAC Rubenesque Paint Pot and Laura Mercier’s Metallic Creme Eye Color in Gold. Note that these swatches were applied with a brush, I found that MAC’s Chilled on Ice and Vintage Selection applied much more smoothly with finger application than you see in this swatch (here, n neutral light):
Same order, in sunlight (click to enlarge):
Chilled on Ice and Vintage Selection were my top choices for an easy, neutral eye with my light skin tone. I was tempted by the other colors, and you may be too, if you look at KarlaSugar’s swatches and Sabrina’s review at The Beauty Look Book.